John Proctor: The Unlikely Villain in This Powerfully Pop-Inspired \’Crucible\’ Reimagining

In the opening line of \”John Proctor Is the Villain,\” we hear the term \”sex,\” foreshadowing what follows. Assigned as the high school English instructor responsible for teaching sex ed to his junior honors class, Mr. Smith (played by Gabriel Ebert) primarily involves having them read out loud various terms such as “sex” along with emphasizing abstinence. This approach does little justice to providing comprehensive sexual education, and clearly, Mr. Smith seems ill-suited for this role. However, since it’s the sole high school within an isolated community nestled in Appalachian Georgia—a place marked more by simplicity than sophistication—he must take up the challenge despite his inadequacies. In essence, part of his core responsibility includes instructing these young minds about Arthur Miller\’s work, particularly focusing on \”The Crucible.\”
,
a nearly universal coming-of-age experience for most American schoolchildren
.
He tells his students that Arthur Miller employed the Salem witch trials of 1692 as a metaphor for McCarthyism in that era. This play is set in 2018, so to make it relevant for them, he connects it with current discussions around \’witch hunts,\’ such as those surrounding the #MeToo movement.

However, #MeToo goes beyond just being a setting or theme. Playwright Kimberly Belfower offers an engaging counterargument to \”The Crucible,\” challenging common interpretations of the play (which her title explicitly indicates). By updating the narrative, she transforms Miller’s portrayal of the Red Scare into something more relevant for today’s political landscape. This transformation lends new vitality to \”The Crucible,\” particularly through the perspective—and rejection—of the teenage female students in the classroom. Additionally, Belfower experiments with the use of allegory, creating a meta-theatrical piece that revises \”The Crucible.\”
,
with different characters serving as stand-ins for Miller\’s and comparable moments reimagined.

Beth (played with tenderness and humor by Fina Strazza), embodies our devoted yet uncertain Mary Warren; Amalia Yoo portrays the loyal but deceived Raelynn (Raelynn, brought to life subtly and sincerely by Amalia Yoo), taking on the role of a youthful Goody Proctor; and Shelby (portrayed by Sadie Sink known for her role in \”Stranger Things\”), assumes the character of Gen Z’s Abigail Williams. In this version, however, Shelby transforms from a scandalously sexually active girl into a determined survivor who chooses not to remain silent anymore.

It’s praiseworthy that Sink has decided to use her celebrity status and drawing power for this production, reflecting her political stance, her growth as an artist, and arguably most significantly, her modesty. In contrast, on Broadway, prominent figures from movies and TV often appear in self-serving endeavors aimed at resurrecting old works.
Shakespeare
,
Mamet
, and even
their own film
Instead, Sink takes part in a group performance, contributing to a fresh, feminist play written by a female playwright. The production is helmed by Danya Taymor, who also directed \”The Outsiders,\” and boasts a predominantly female creative staff.

Sink delivers a captivating portrayal as a young woman whose heartache runs deep yet wears a tough exterior. Despite being intelligent, she often faces underestimation and channels her anger towards combating gender inequality. Supported by an exceptional ensemble cast that shares excellent chemistry, Belflower crafts well-rounded personalities even for minor parts such as the transplanted Atlantan character Nell played by Morgan Scott, or Mason portrayed by Nihan Duvvuri—a self-proclaimed male feminist. Bridging the gap between pupils and educator stands Ms. Gallagher, vividly enacted by Molly Griggs, who serves both as a recent graduate from the same institution and a newly minted counselor offering pivotal support during critical moments.

A group of girls in their class, spearheaded by Beth who carries a big binder, unite to create a feminism club. Initially, this idea faces rejection from school authorities but gains support when Mr. Smith volunteers as the advisor and Mason gets involved unwillingly. While studying Arthur Miller’s “The Crucible” and holding regular club sessions, they uncover various scandals, turning discussions about #MeToo into highly personal matters that challenge these young women\’s beliefs and commitments to feminism.

Belflower adeptly portrays how deeply embedded pop music becomes within the everyday speech of these adolescent females, interlacing lyrics from artists like Taylor Swift, Beyoncé, Lizzo, and Lorde throughout. These young women rely on contemporary hits as touchstones for their nascent feminist views and to articulate the intense feelings characteristic of youth. When faced with difficult moments, they find solace in melodies. During the peak moment of the drama, two students perform an expressive dance to a meticulously chosen pop track during a class presentation on “The Crucible.” Their rendition is emotionally stirring, raw, cleansing, making it one of the most impactful climaxes seen recently onstage.

In yet another standout moment, Raelynn and Shelby play hooky and spend their time at a convenience store. After enduring significant turbulence in their long-standing friendship, this poignant sequence captures them grappling with past traumas side by side. What elevates this scene is how authentically it depicts the distinctive manner adolescent females communicate in private: complete with their mutual vernacular, body language, secret gags, deep closeness, and fits of laughter that bring about physical pain. The brilliance stems from Belflower’s prose, Taymor’s guidance, and the compelling portrayals delivered by Sink and Yoo, merging beautifully to craft an enchanting experience.

Throughout Taymor’s guidance, every aspect shines brilliantly; however, she truly excels in subtleties within numerous minor elements. Her handling of scene shifts stands as remarkable artistic achievements individually. Following each segment, an actor remains onstage, providing us with poignant postscripts—silent monologues revealing their inner thoughts and emotions over another sixty seconds. Accompanying these moments, sound designer and composer Palmer Hefferan injects haunting electronic music into the space, while lighting director Natasha Katz and projection artist Hannah Wasilke craft subtle visual effects that cast ominous glows across the classroom setting, enhancing the unsettling atmosphere almost akin to a macabre stage design. This technique masterfully amplifies tension during pauses between acts, turning those brief intervals into impactful narrative segments.

This production features multiple plot twists that escalate tension and sustain the rapid pace of the performance; these elements feel genuinely achieved rather than forced. Classroom walls adorned with images representing \’aha\’ moments reflect such instances throughout the show, particularly when Shelby—ironically yet appropriately—asserts that John Proctor serves as the antagonist in \”The Crucible.” This statement causes consternation for Mr. Smith, who upholds Proctor’s heroic virtues. However, Shelby’s insight ignites an epiphany among her classmates. As a result, this theatrical piece could fundamentally alter your perspective on “The Crucible,” introducing new dimensions and complex interpretations through a feminist lens that contrasts sharply with conventional educational approaches.

\”John Proctor Is the Villain\” stands out as the premier play of this season; however, it also emerges as a significant feminist achievement destined to be recognized as one of the hallmark artworks stemming from and reflecting upon the #MeToo movement. Much like how \”The Great Gatsby\” has been interpreted over time,
also on Broadway
Another popular choice among high schools, this play also delves into what Belflower adeptly captured—a snapshot of an ongoing event. The narrative unfolds in 2018, the year Belflower initially presented the work as part of a workshop. Even with such limited time between these events and their portrayal, BelfLOWER manages to maintain clear insight into the intricacies surrounding the #MeToo movement. This includes not only significant transgressions but minor ones too, the swift propagation of feminist passion, the critical importance of beginning to trust women’s accounts, and the often unsettling pace at which cancel culture has evolved.

The play poses the crucial question: at what point does an investigation turn into a witch hunt? It also prompts us to reflect on who is labeled as a witch, who takes on the role of the hunter, and whether those targeted deserve such treatment. \”\’John Proctor Is the Villain\’\” represents a feminist reinterpretation, recasting \’The Crucible.\’
\”
It turns everything upside down and showcases the strength of female unity and fury — currently, these seem like solid tactics for resisting or simply getting through tough times. This production fits perfectly with our current situation; it’s an immediate reaction to a period marked by crises and serves as a rallying cry amidst a frightening reality. Thus, let\’s head into the forest, howl at the sky, tear it all apart, and construct something superior and more hopeful collectively.